Parliament and Central Legislature

The Parliament of India is the supreme legislative body of the country — the institution through which the people’s sovereignty is exercised. Established under Part V of the Constitution, the Indian Parliament consists of three components: the President of India, the Rajya Sabha (Council of States), and the Lok Sabha (House of the People). Together, these three constitute Parliament. For KPSC KAS aspirants, Parliament is a foundational topic — it is tested not only for knowledge of its structure and functions but also for understanding the legislative process, parliamentary privileges, and the delicate balance between the three branches of government. Karnataka’s own parliamentary representation — the state’s 28 Lok Sabha seats and 12 Rajya Sabha seats — reflects its significant weight in the national political landscape, and Karnataka has produced several prominent Parliamentarians, including notable Speakers of Lok Sabha and Chairpersons of Rajya Sabha.

Understanding Parliament means understanding not just its formal structure but the political dynamics that shape how it functions. The relationship between the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha, the role of the President in the legislative process, the committee system, and the ever-present tension between executive dominance and legislative oversight — these are the themes that animate parliamentary studies in the Indian context.

---

🟢 Lite — Quick Review

The Three Components of Parliament:

1. The President — The head of state who summons, prorogues, and dissolves Parliament; assent to bills; and addresses Parliament at the beginning of each session.
2. Lok Sabha — The lower house, with members elected directly by adult suffrage for a 5-year term. Maximum 552 members (530 states, 20 Union Territories, 2 Anglo-Indian nominations by President).
3. Rajya Sabha — The upper house, with members elected by state legislatures for a 6-year term, with one-third retiring every 2 years. Maximum 250 members (238 state representatives, 12 nominated by President for expertise in literature, art, science, and social service).

Types of Bills:

• Money Bill (Article 110) — Deals with taxation, borrowing, consolidated fund, contingency fund. Only Lok Sabha can introduce. Speaker’s certification is final.
• Financial Bill — Broader than Money Bill, includes expenditure from the consolidated fund. Can be introduced in either house.
• Ordinary Bill — Any other bill. Can be introduced in either house.

Key parliamentary terms: Adjournment, Prorogation, Dissolution, Question Hour, Zero Hour, Calling Attention Motion, Privilege Motion, No-Confidence Motion.

⚡ Exam tip: A very common KPSC question asks: “Distinguish between a Money Bill and a Financial Bill.” Remember that Money Bills deal only with matters listed in Article 110(1), are certified by the Speaker, and can only be introduced in Lok Sabha. Financial Bills are broader and follow the ordinary legislative process but require Presidential recommendation for certain provisions.

---

🟡 Standard — Regular Study

The President and Parliament

The President of India is an integral part of Parliament — no bill can become law without the President’s assent. However, the President is not a member of Parliament and does not participate in parliamentary debates. The President’s role is formal and convention-bound rather than political.

Article 78 defines the President’s relationship with the Council of Ministers: the President exercises powers on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister. This is the convention of ministerial responsibility — the government is responsible to Parliament, and the President acts on ministerial advice.

Summoning and Prorogation: The President summons each house to meet at the beginning of each session (there are usually three sessions: Budget, Monsoon, and Winter) and can prorogue (end) a session. The President can also dissolve Lok Sabha (on advice of the Council of Ministers) — this triggers fresh elections within 6 months.

Assent to Bills: When a bill is passed by both houses, it is presented to the President, who can either assent or withhold assent. The President can also return a bill (other than a Money Bill) to Parliament for reconsideration — but if Parliament passes it again (with or without changes), the President must give assent. This is a discretionary power — the President acts on ministerial advice in most cases, but some Presidents (like Rajendra Prasad and Zail Singh) have used this power to return bills for reconsideration on significant occasions.

Article 123 gives the President the power to promulgate ordinances when Parliament is not in session. An ordinance has the same force as an Act of Parliament but must be laid before Parliament when it reconvenes and ceases to operate if not approved within 6 weeks. Karnataka’s Governor has similar ordinance-making power under Article 213.

Lok Sabha — The House of the People

The Lok Sabha is the directly elected house and is considered the lower house (though the Constitution does not explicitly use this term). It has a maximum term of 5 years, though it can be dissolved earlier or extended during a National Emergency.

Composition: Members of Lok Sabha (MLAs in the sense of MPs — the term MLA is used for state legislature members) are elected from territorial constituencies through first-past-the-post voting — the candidate with the most votes wins, even if not a majority. Karnataka has 28 Lok Sabha seats, reflecting its population (2011 Census). Delimitation of constituencies is done by the Delimitation Commission after each Census.

Special powers of Lok Sabha: The Lok Sabha has exclusive power to:

• Approve financial proposals (Money Bills)
• Remove the government through a no-confidence motion
• Election of the President (along with Rajya Sabha)
• Impeachment of the President (along with Rajya Sabha)

Disqualification: Under the Tenth Schedule (added by the 52nd Amendment, 1985), a member of Parliament can be disqualified for defection — if they voluntarily give up party membership or vote against party directions on a money bill or constitutional amendment. However, the Supreme Court in Kihoto Hollohan v. Zachillhu (1992) held that the Speakers’ disqualification decisions are subject to judicial review — though Speakers act as quasi-judicial bodies, their decisions can be challenged in court.

Rajya Sabha — The Council of States

The Rajya Sabha represents the states of India — it is a federal chamber where states have representation based on population (minimum 1, maximum 31 for each state). Karnataka has 12 Rajya Sabha members. Rajya Sabha members are elected by the elected members of the State Legislative Assembly through proportional representation using a single transferable vote — a system designed to ensure representation for minority parties and independent members.

Permanent nature: Unlike Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha is a permanent house — it is not subject to dissolution. One-third of its members retire every 2 years and are replaced by newly elected members. This gives Rajya Sabha continuity.

Special powers of Rajya Sabha: Rajya Sabha has equal powers with Lok Sabha in most legislative matters except Money Bills. Rajya Sabha can:

• Recommend creation of new states (Article 3) — though any bill affecting a state’s boundaries must be referred to that state’s legislature
• Elect the President (along with Lok Sabha)
• Impeach the President, Vice President, and judges of Supreme Court and High Courts (along with Lok Sabha)
• Pass a resolution declaring a National Emergency (along with Lok Sabha)

The cooling-off period for a defeated bill: Under Article 108, if a bill (other than a Money Bill) is not passed by both houses (because Rajya Sabha rejects it or takes no action), a joint sitting can be convened where the will of the majority prevails. This has happened only three times: for the Dowry Prohibition Act (1960), the Banking Service Commission Act (1984), and the Preventive Detention Act (1985).

⚡ Exam tip: The joint sitting provision is important for understanding the relative power of Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha. In a joint sitting, the Lok Sabha’s larger membership (currently 543 vs Rajya Sabha’s 233) effectively gives it the upper hand. However, this is a rarely used emergency mechanism.

Law-Making Process

The legislative process in Parliament follows these stages:

1. Introduction: A bill can be introduced by any member. For certain bills (relating to subjects in the Union List), Presidential recommendation is required before introduction.
2. First Reading: The bill is introduced and its title is read out. The House may take the bill into consideration or form a committee.
3. Second Reading: The bill is discussed in detail. Members can propose amendments, deletions, or additions. This is the most substantive stage.
4. Committee Stage: The bill may be referred to a Select Committee (for one house) or a Joint Committee (both houses). Committee stage allows detailed, expert examination of the bill.
5. Report Stage: The committee reports the bill back to the House with or without amendments.
6. Third Reading: The bill is voted upon in its entirety — members can only accept or reject, not amend (with limited exceptions).
7. Other House: The bill is transmitted to the other house, which follows the same process.
8. Presidential Assent: After both houses pass the bill, it is presented to the President for assent.
9. Gazette Publication: The Act is published in the Official Gazette and comes into force on the date specified or notified.

⚡ Exam tip: KPSC frequently asks about the difference between a Money Bill and a Financial Bill and the stages of the legislative process. Also be clear about what Presidential recommendation is required for — Article 117 requires Presidential recommendation for Money Bills and bills that involve expenditure from the Consolidated Fund.

Parliamentary Privileges

Parliamentary privileges are special rights and immunities enjoyed by members of Parliament and the two houses collectively to enable them to function effectively without interference. These are codified in Article 105.

Individual privileges: Each MP has the right to:

• Freedom of speech in Parliament (subject to the Constitution and rules)
• Freedom from arrest in civil cases during a session and 40 days before and after
• Freedom from being compelled to give evidence in any court regarding parliamentary proceedings

Collective privileges: Each house has the right to:

• Regulate its internal proceedings
• Punish members for breach of privilege (including suspension)
• Expel members
• Call for persons and papers (enforced by the President’s Mace — the symbol of the house’s authority)
• Publish reports and debates (though the house can forbid publication)

Breach of Privilege: If a member or outsider interferes with parliamentary proceedings — for example, by intimidating a member, publishing a false or scandalous report of parliamentary proceedings, or obstructing the house’s work — it constitutes a breach of privilege and contempt of the house. The house can punish the offender. However, the Supreme Court in Kushal Bhardwaj v. State of UP and other cases has held that parliamentary privilege does not override Fundamental Rights and that courts can adjudicate on whether privilege has been properly invoked.

In Karnataka: The Karnataka Legislative Assembly and Karnataka Legislative Council have similar privileges under Article 195 (state legislature privileges mirror Parliament’s privileges by reference). The Karnataka Legislative Assembly’s Powers and Privileges Act is the specific legislation governing this.

⚡ Exam tip: A common KPSC question is about Article 105 vs Article 194 — parliamentary privileges at the central and state levels. Note that while Article 105 applies to Parliament, Article 194 applies to state legislatures and provides broader privileges — this was addressed in the Case of Haryana vs Bhajan Lal (1992) and other cases.

Financial Procedure — Budget and Money Bills

Article 265 provides that no tax can be imposed or altered except by law. This means the government’s revenue proposals must go through the full legislative process — Parliament controls the purse strings. This is the principle of parliamentary control over finance.

The Budget cycle:

1. Budget Presentation: The Finance Minister presents the Annual Financial Statement (the Budget) in Lok Sabha. This is usually in February.
2. General Discussion: The budget is discussed but not voted upon.
3. Committee Stage: The detailed examination is done by the Estimates Committee (examining expenditure estimates), the Public Accounts Committee (examining how money was actually spent), and the Standing Committee on Finance.
4. Voting on Demands for Grants: Lok Sabha votes on individual demands for grants — this is where MPs can reject or reduce proposals.
5. Appropriation Bill: After voting, the Appropriation Bill (authorising expenditure from the Consolidated Fund) is passed.
6. Finance Bill: Separately, the Finance Bill (containing tax proposals) is passed.
7. President’s Assent: Both bills receive Presidential assent.

Article 110 defines a Money Bill — it must deal only with: taxation, borrowing, consolidated fund, contingency fund, or matters incidental to these. The Speaker of Lok Sabha certifies whether a bill is a Money Bill — this certificate is final and cannot be questioned in any court. However, in Kihoto Hollohan (1992), the Court held that the Speaker’s certificate can be challenged if it is malicious or perverse.

⚡ Exam tip: Karnataka’s own budget process mirrors the Parliament’s — the Karnataka Fiscal Responsibility Act (similar to the central FRBM Act) mandates fiscal discipline. Karnataka’s Karnataka State Budget is presented by the Finance Minister before the Legislative Assembly. The Karnataka Comptroller and Auditor General audits state accounts.

---

🔴 Extended — Deep Study

No-Confidence Motion

A no-confidence motion is a parliamentary mechanism through which Lok Sabha can remove the government. Under Article 75(3), the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to Lok Sabha — if Lok Sabha withdraws its confidence, the government must resign.

Procedure: A no-confidence motion requires the support of at least 50 members (10% of Lok Sabha’s strength). If the motion is passed by a simple majority, the government must resign. If it fails, the members who moved it cannot move another no-confidence motion for the remainder of that session.

Historical significance: Several no-confidence motions have been moved in Indian parliamentary history. The first was in 1963 (against the Nehru government). The most significant was the no-confidence motion against the Indira Gandhi government in 1975 — which preceded the declaration of the Emergency. The motion was defeated, but it triggered the Congress party’s internal split and the subsequent Emergency. More recently, the 2019 no-confidence motion against the NDA government (moved by the TDP and others regarding Andhra Pradesh’s special status) was debated extensively in Lok Sabha.

Related mechanisms:

• Privilege Motion: Used to enforce accountability of the executive to Parliament — if a minister makes a false statement or violates parliamentary privilege.
• Adjournment Motion: A parliamentary device to interrupt normal business to discuss an urgent matter of public importance — requires the Speaker’s permission.
• Censure Motion: Unlike a no-confidence motion, a censure motion does not require the government to resign — it expresses disapproval of the government’s conduct.

Karnataka context: Karnataka has seen several no-confidence motions in the Legislative Assembly — the No-Confidence Motion against the Janata Dal (Secular) — Congress coalition government in 2019 was notable. Understanding no-confidence motions at the state level helps illustrate parliamentary accountability in practice.

Parliamentary Committees

The parliamentary committee system is the engine room of legislative work. Most bills and financial proposals are examined in committee rather than on the floor of the house — committees allow detailed, specialised scrutiny that the full house cannot provide.

Types of Committees:

1. Standing Committees (Permanent):

   • Committee on Estimates (30 members): Examines expenditure estimates of ministries — whether funds are being used effectively and whether savings are possible. Karnataka equivalent: Estimates Committee of the Legislative Assembly.
   • Public Accounts Committee (PAC) (22 members — 15 from Lok Sabha, 7 from Rajya Sabha): Examines the CAG’s audit reports to determine whether money was spent as authorised. The PAC is chaired by a senior opposition member — this is an important convention.
   • Committee on Public Undertakings (COPU): Examines the working of public sector undertakings.
   • Standing Committee on Finance: Examines finance bills and monetary policy.

2. Select Committees and Joint Committees: Set up for specific bills — a Select Committee is appointed by one house; a Joint Committee is appointed by both houses. After the 1990s, the practice of referring important bills to Joint Committees has increased.

3. Departmentally Related Standing Committees (DRSC): Established in 1993, there are 24 DRSCs covering all ministries. They examine bills, reports, and policies of their respective ministries.

4. Select Committee on a Bill: Appointed by the house to examine a specific bill in detail. After examination, the committee reports back to the house.

Committee system in Karnataka: The Karnataka Legislative Assembly has its own committee system — the Public Accounts Committee (Karnataka), Estimates Committee, and Committee on Government Assurances are particularly important. The Karnataka RTI Act’s implementation is monitored by these committees.

⚡ Exam tip: KPSC frequently asks about the Public Accounts Committee’s composition and role — remember that it is chaired by a senior opposition member (convention) and that its function is to examine audit reports, not to authorise expenditure (that’s the Estimates Committee’s role).

The Speaker of Lok Sabha

The Speaker of Lok Sabha is one of the most powerful offices in the Indian parliamentary system. The Speaker is elected from among Lok Sabha members at the beginning of each Lok Sabha and continues in office until a new Lok Sabha is constituted.

Powers and Functions:

• Presides over Lok Sabha proceedings — maintains order, allows or disallows members to speak, interprets rules
• Certifies Money Bills (Article 110) — the Speaker’s certificate is final
• Disqualifies members under the Tenth Schedule (anti-defection law) — though this decision is now subject to judicial review (Kihoto Hollohan)
• Appoints chairpersons of various committees
• Controls the agenda of Lok Sabha
• Lien on the Chair: Once a Speaker is elected, the office is independent of the ruling party — the Speaker does not resign from the party but is expected to act impartially

Notable Speakers of Lok Sabha: Ganesh Vasudev Mavalankar (first Speaker), Jogendranath Mandal, M. Ananda S. Bal (Karnataka — served as Speaker in the 7th Lok Sabha), P.M. Sayeed, Somnath Chatterjee (13th Lok Sabha — faced significant political controversy), Meira Kumar (first woman Speaker), and Om Birla (current).

Karnataka connection: Karnataka has contributed several Speakers to Lok Sabha — M. Ananda S. Bal served as Speaker of the 7th Lok Sabha (1989–1991). Karnataka’s own Legislative Assembly Speaker — the Karnataka Vidhana Soudha (the legislative building) has seen significant political events, including the Karnataka political crisis of 1980s and 2019-2020, when the assembly’s stability and the Speaker’s decisions were central to government formation.

Speaker’s Casting Vote: The Speaker can vote in Lok Sabha (unlike the Chairman of Rajya Sabha, who does not vote unless there is a tie — and when there is a tie, the question is deemed not passed). This difference is significant — it reflects the Lok Sabha’s role as the directly elected, politically accountable house.

⚡ Exam tip: KPSC Mains questions often ask about the role of the Speaker in controlling parliamentary proceedings and the Speaker’s certificate power regarding Money Bills. A nuanced answer would mention the tension between the Speaker’s political affiliation and the expectation of impartiality — and would reference the Kihoto Hollohan case where the Court said the Speaker’s quasi-judicial functions under the anti-defection law are subject to judicial review.

Parliamentary Accountability and the Executive

A critical dimension of parliamentary study is the mechanisms through which Parliament holds the executive accountable:

• Question Hour: Every sitting begins with Question Hour — members ask ministers questions. There are three types: Starred Questions (answered orally, with supplementary questions), Unstarred Questions (answered in writing, no supplementary), and Short Notice Questions (for urgent matters).
• Zero Hour: After Question Hour, Zero Hour allows members to raise matters of urgent importance without prior notice.
• Calling Attention Motion: A member can call the attention of a minister to a matter of urgent public importance.
• Adjournment Motion: As discussed above.
• No-Confidence Motion: As discussed above.
• Censure Motion: Expresses disapproval of government policy without seeking resignation.
• Election of Speaker and Deputy Speakers: A symbolic assertion of Lok Sabha’s authority.

Parliamentary Sessions in Karnataka: Karnataka’s Legislative Assembly follows a similar calendar — Budget Session (February-March), Monsoon Session (July-August), and Winter Session (November-December). The Karnataka Legislative Council (the upper house of Karnataka’s bicameral legislature) is a permanent house, similar to Rajya Sabha. Karnataka has a bicameral legislature — one of the few states with a Council (others include Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, and Telangana).

⚡ Exam tip: For KPSC, understanding the comparative structure of Parliament and Karnataka’s legislature is important. Karnataka has the Vidhana Sabha (lower house), Vidhana Parishad (upper house), and the Governor — this mirrors the Parliament’s structure with some key differences (the Governor’s role is more limited than the President’s). Also note that Karnataka is one of the 15 states with a bicameral legislature — the others are Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Jammu & Kashmir, Karnataka, Kerala, Maharashtra, Nagaland, Punjab, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu, Telangana, Uttar Pradesh, Uttarakhand, and West Bengal.

Parliamentary elections and Karnataka: Karnataka’s 28 Lok Sabha seats (after 2008 delimitation) are significant in national politics — the state has been a battleground between the BJP, Congress, and JD(S). The Karnataka Assembly elections (held every 5 years, often not synchronised with Lok Sabha elections) have significant implications for the state’s governance and its representation in Parliament.